The Promise 10

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Wednesday, 12 June 2013

Lost in the Nuclear Clouds

Posted on 11:20 by Unknown

I watched Cloud Atlas (2012) over the last two nights (it’s almost 3 hours long) and was surprised that one plotline involves a nuclear energy facility, at least tangentially.

If you haven’t seen the movie, it tells six distinct stories in widely variant time periods, each in its own style. Like D.W. Griffith’s similarly structured Intolerance (1916), its stories are built around a common theme – in the case of Cloud Atlas, the interconnectedness of everyone through eternity.

To bring this point home, many of the actors play roles in all six stories, crossing gender, racial and ethnic lines. This is different than the David Mitchell novel the movie is based on, which doesn’t suggest the characters reincarnate; the novel also tells the six stories sequentially while the movie intercuts them, sometimes in very quick shots, to make the theme and the connections clearer.

All this sounds tricky, even gimmicky, but the filmmakers (the Wachowski siblings and Tom Tykwer) work very hard to keep the stories coherent. The nuclear plant story, put together by Tykwer, is probably the most coherent because it uses the familiar framework of a 70s paranoid thriller (think The Parallax View (1973) or Klute (1970)) to tell of a reporter (Halle Berry) who uncovers a vast conspiracy that involves the purposeful sabotage of a new nuclear facility.

When I broke at the ninety minute mark the first night, this section played like the mutant spawn of The China Syndrome (1979)and Silkwood  (1982). I didn’t expect the second half to go well, especially after the intrepid heroine’s car is forced to plummet into a lake by a shadowy assassin (Hugo Weaving) employed by the shadowy nuclear plant.

Let’s pause and expand on the idea of nuclear energy as a villainous force. There’s no particular reason to get exercised by movie ideas like atomic twisters or evil energy executives having likeable young people killed. Movies, especially thrillers and other genre movies, don’t particularly care if their treatment of a subject lacks objectivity or accuracy; audiences understand this because they quite reasonably want action and thrills, not an essay on the perils or benefits of nuclear energy. The villain is a villain – just give him or her silky diction, darkly ridiculous motivations and enough henchmen to get their shadowy cabal union cards. Then, let the mayhem commence.

But – resuming our review of the story -

Cloud Atlas did not choose nuclear energy as its viper du jour. Quite the opposite. <Note: spoilers ahead, so if you haven’t seen the movie, stop reading now>.

An army friend (Keith David) of Berry’s deceased father (who was also a journalist) enters the story and reveals to Berry (she survives her trip into the water; surprised?) that the evil spider den is actually  occupied by disgruntled gas and oil executives who want nuclear power to fail because “it is the energy of the future.” These executives, led by a rotted looking Hugh Grant, are afraid of being rendered irrelevant. You could have knocked me over with a fuel rod at that revelation, but there it is.

Cloud Atlas is meant to be taken fairly seriously while delivering a load of entertainment and a fortune cookie moral. I’m not underestimating the filmmakers’ desire to have of fun with the premise – they know that the movie’s busy narrative agenda is almost a parody of ambition, so why not add a little fun?

Tykwer achieves this by setting the nuclear/oil segment in the 70s and evoking the style of that period by aping the moviemaking techniques and ideas of the time. But the titles it is referencing were interesting, well-done thrillers, not fat slabs of cheese. Even The China Syndrome is genuinely suspenseful if fantastically mendacious. The decision to take this approach, which occasionally turns Halle Berry into Pam Grier’s karate chopping Foxy Brown, makes the irresponsibility of the segment really glare. Just because the nuclear energy industry is absolved of wrongdoing (whew!) and given a shout out doesn’t make the conceit less problematic.

So, the segment’s not free of problems, but it isn’t the second coming of The China Syndrome, either. is Cloud Atlas a good movie overall? Well, the comparison to Intolerance remains apt: like its 95 year old precursor, it’s big, often silly when it means to be serious and the treatment of the theme is very, very blunt.

But it is also gigantic in scope, shot through with narrative if not thematic ambition and extremely well performed (the actors in all their roles are fascinating to watch – some of it feels genuinely transgressive, especially in light of the Larry-to-Lana Wachowski transition). It is, like many recent movies, an audio-visual experience rather than an affecting piece of work. You may come out of it feeling pummeled by the propulsion of its imagery, but at least not too annoyed at the filmmakers for their rather cavalier treatment of the atom.

---

With the opening of Pandora’s Promise Friday, let’s consider this movie week at NEI Nuclear Notes.

Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in Cloud Atlas, Nuclear Energy | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Shift in Clinton Plant Refueling Cycle Increases Efficiency
    NEI’s Top Industry Practice Awards recognize innovation in the nuclear energy industry. Presented at NEI’s annual conference, the awards h...
  • The Unofficial Guide to Pandora's Promise, a Documentary Film About Nuclear Energy by Robert Stone (Bumped)
    Updated Editor's Note: The next big date on the Pandora's Promise calendar is November 7 at 9:00 p.m. U.S. EST. That's when the ...
  • A Nuclear-Powered Space Rover Lands on Mars, Brings New Hope for Space Exploration
    “If anybody has been harboring doubts about the status of U.S. leadership in space, well, there’s a one-ton, automobile-size piece of Americ...
  • A Man, A Plan, A Canal–Panama! – Oh, and A Floating Reactor, Too
    Floating nuclear energy stations, highlighted by the Russian effort noted below, are not a new phenomenon and represent a further develo...
  • Turkey Wants Reactors – But How Many?
    We have nothing to say about Germany today, but we know what it could do with its nuclear plants if it really wants to close them down: ...
  • NuScale Back in Action with Unexpected Support
    The other day, we mentioned Babcock & Wilcox’s small reactor project and its indirect use in the Gubernatorial race in Indiana. Now, ano...
  • Can You Make an Ethical Case for Nuclear Energy?
    Over the course of the history of NEI Nuclear Notes, I've assiduously avoided sharing coverage from the financial press for a variety of...
  • The Best Nuclear Energy News of 2013
    Your list of the best nuclear news of the year, part 1, and in no particular order. All good news is number 1, right? 1. Pandora’s Pro...
  • World Bank Toff: “We don’t do nuclear energy.”
    So says World Bank President Jim Yong Kim: “We don’t do nuclear energy.” Okay. “The World Bank Group does not engage in ...
  • A Nuclear Namibia Nearer Than Naught?
    If you’ve read enough of our posts here, you know we like to keep up with what’s happening around the world – who’s interested in nuclear en...

Categories

  • #CNOSummit
  • 123 agreement
  • 2012 Elections
  • 2012 India Blackout
  • 2012 Nuclear Energy Assembly
  • 2013 Nuclear Energy Assembly
  • 2013 State of the Union
  • 316b
  • 60th Anniversary
  • 9-11
  • ABC
  • Advanced Research Projects Agency
  • advertising
  • Africa
  • Agreement States
  • aircraft impact
  • Al Gore
  • Alabama
  • Alan J. Kuperman
  • Albania
  • Alec Baldwin
  • Alex Flint
  • Allison Macfarlane
  • Amber Lyon
  • Amber Lyons
  • Ameren Missouri
  • American Electric Power
  • American Power Act
  • American Wind Energy Association
  • Andrew Revkin
  • Anil Kadkodkar
  • Ann Bisconti
  • AP1000
  • Apple
  • AREVA
  • argonne national lab
  • Arizona Public Service
  • Arizona Strip
  • Arkansas Nuclear One
  • Arnie Gundersen
  • Associated
  • Associated Press
  • Atomic Industrial Forum
  • atoms for peace
  • Australia
  • Babcock and Wilcox
  • Bangladesh
  • Barack Obama
  • Barclays
  • baseload
  • battery 500
  • Belgium
  • Berlin
  • Bezdek
  • Bhopal
  • Bill Gates
  • Billie Garde
  • Billy Jack
  • Bisconti
  • Blogging
  • Blue Castle
  • blue fin tuna
  • Blue Ribbon Commission
  • bluefin tuna
  • Bob Bishop
  • Bolivia
  • Breakthrough Institute
  • BREDL
  • Britain
  • Brown's Ferry
  • Browns Ferry
  • Bulgaria
  • butterflies
  • California
  • California Energy Commission
  • Callaway
  • Calvert Cliffs
  • Canada
  • cancer
  • Cape Cod Times
  • Carbon Emissions
  • carbon tax
  • Caroline Cochran
  • CASEnergy Coalition
  • Center for Advanced Energy Research
  • cesium
  • Charles Till
  • Charlotte
  • China
  • Chip Pardee
  • Chris Crane
  • Clean Energy
  • clean energy standard
  • climate change
  • Clinton Nuclear Power Station
  • Cloud Atlas
  • CNN
  • coal
  • cold fusion
  • Columbia Journalism Review
  • common language
  • Congress
  • Constellation Energy
  • cooling tower
  • cost recovery
  • crocodiles
  • Crystal River
  • CSIS
  • Curio
  • Curiosity
  • CWIP
  • Cyber Security
  • Czech Republic
  • D.C. Cook
  • Daily Kos
  • Daily Show
  • Dale Klein
  • Dan Lipman
  • data centers
  • David Allard
  • David Fitzpatrick
  • David Lochbaum
  • debate
  • defense
  • Denmark
  • Department of Atomic Energy (India)
  • Department of Energy
  • Department of Homeland Security
  • Department of the Interior
  • Design Basis Threat
  • Diego Garcia
  • Dominion
  • Dominion Resources
  • Dominion Virginia Power
  • Dr. Patrick Moore
  • Dr. Robert Peter Gale
  • Drew Griffin
  • Duane Arnold
  • Duke Energy
  • Dwight Eisenhower
  • Earth Day
  • earthquake
  • East Coast Earthquake
  • economic benefits
  • Ed Halpin
  • EDF
  • Edison
  • education
  • efficiency
  • EIA
  • Einstein Medical Center Montgomery
  • Elaine Grossman
  • electric vehicles
  • electricity
  • emergency alert system
  • emergency planning zone
  • emergency preparedness
  • emergency response
  • energy
  • energy diversity
  • energy information administration
  • Energy Northwest
  • Energy Secretary Chu
  • Entergy
  • Entergy Arkansas
  • environment
  • Environment America
  • EPA
  • EPZ
  • Eric Lax
  • Eric Schmitz
  • Ernest Moniz
  • ERO
  • Eskom
  • ethical investing
  • european union
  • Exelon
  • Exelon Nuclear
  • Export-Import Bank
  • Facebook
  • Fairewinds Associates
  • FBI
  • filtered vents
  • Financial Reporter
  • Finland
  • First Energy
  • FitzPatrick Plant
  • FLEX
  • Florida
  • Florida Power and Light
  • Florida State Senate
  • Fluor
  • food critic
  • Forbes
  • Fox News
  • FPL
  • France
  • Francois Hollande
  • Fred McGoldrick
  • Friends of the Earth
  • Frontline
  • Fukushima Daiichi
  • Fukushima Daini
  • fusion
  • Gallup Poll
  • GAO
  • GE Hitachi Nuclear Energy Award
  • General Atomics
  • Georgetown University
  • Georgia
  • Georgia Power
  • Germany
  • Ghana
  • Ginger Zee
  • Global Nuclear Energy Partnership
  • Global Security Newswire
  • gold standard
  • Google
  • Gov. Jerry Brown
  • Governor Jay Nixon
  • Governor Mitt Romney
  • Great Britain
  • Green Bay
  • Green Energy
  • Green Party
  • greenhouse gases
  • Greenpeace
  • Gregory Jaczko
  • grid reliability
  • Ground Water
  • Gunther Oettinger
  • Gwyneth Cravens
  • Hanford
  • Health Physics
  • Health Physics Society
  • heat wave
  • Helen Caldicott
  • Henry Sokolski
  • Heritage Foundation
  • Higher Education
  • Holtec International
  • House Committee on Energy and Commerce
  • House Foreign Affairs Committee
  • HR 2449
  • Hurricane Sandy
  • hydrogen
  • Hyperion
  • IAEA
  • ibm
  • Idaho
  • Idaho National Lab
  • IEA
  • IEEE
  • Illinois
  • incentives
  • India
  • India Ink
  • Indian Point
  • IndyCar
  • INPO
  • Inside Climate News
  • inspiration
  • international trade
  • Iowa
  • Iran
  • Italy
  • ITER
  • Ivan Penn
  • James Hansen
  • James Howard
  • James Lovelock
  • Janette Sherman
  • JANSI
  • Japan
  • Japan. PBS
  • Japanese earthquake
  • Jeff Donn
  • Jim Asselstine
  • Jim Slider
  • Jim Tusar
  • JJ Abrams
  • jobs
  • John Kerry
  • Jon Stewart
  • Jordan
  • Joseph Mangano
  • Jr.
  • Junichiro Koizumi
  • Kashiwazaki-Kariwa Nuclear Plant
  • KEPCO
  • Kewaunee
  • Kuwait
  • KV Racing Technology
  • laser enrichment
  • leadership
  • Lehman Brothers
  • Levy County
  • liberal politics
  • license renewal
  • licensing
  • Lithuania
  • Los Angeles Times
  • low-level nuclear waste
  • Ltd
  • M.V. Ramana
  • Maine
  • Mark Bittman
  • Mark Cooper
  • Mark Hibbs
  • Mark Lynas
  • Mark Tercek
  • Mars
  • Marv Fertel
  • Maryland
  • Massachusetts
  • Matt Wald
  • Megatons to Megawatts
  • meteor
  • methane
  • Michael Moore
  • Michael Shellenberger
  • Michigan
  • Mid-American Energy
  • Mike Childs
  • minnesota
  • missouri
  • MIT
  • Mitsubishi
  • Monica Trauzzi
  • Mothers in Nuclear
  • movie review
  • MOX Fuel
  • mPower
  • MSNBC
  • NA-YGN
  • Namibia
  • Naomi Oreskes
  • NARUC
  • NASA
  • Nathan Myhrvold
  • National Academy of Sciences
  • National Association of Manufacturers
  • National Mining Association
  • National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
  • Natural Gas
  • Nature Conservancy
  • NBC
  • NEI
  • NEI.org
  • Nemo
  • Nevada
  • New Hampshire
  • New Jersey
  • New Mexico
  • new nuclear plants
  • new plant licensing
  • New York Times
  • NextEra Energy
  • Nicholas Sarkozy
  • NIRS
  • No Nukes
  • nonproliferation
  • North Anna
  • Northwestern University
  • NRC
  • Nuclear
  • nuclear arms reduction
  • Nuclear Energy
  • Nuclear Energy Assembly
  • Nuclear Energy Institute
  • Nuclear Energy;
  • nuclear energy.
  • nuclear engineering
  • nuclear exports
  • nuclear option
  • nuclear plant
  • nuclear plant design
  • Nuclear plant security
  • nuclear power
  • Nuclear Power Corporation of India
  • Nuclear Proliferation Prevention Project
  • nuclear reactor
  • nuclear regulatory commission
  • Nuclear Safety Inspections
  • Nuclear Suppliers Group
  • nuclear supply chain
  • nuclear waste
  • nuclear waste fund
  • Nuclear Waste Policy Act
  • nuclear weapons
  • nuclear workforce
  • NuScale Power
  • NY AREA
  • Oconee
  • OECD
  • ohi
  • Oil
  • oil sands
  • Oklo
  • Onagawa
  • Ontario Power Generation
  • Opinionator
  • Oregon
  • Oyster Creek
  • pacific ocean
  • Pakistan
  • Palisades Nuclear Power Plant
  • Palo Verde Nuclear Power Plant
  • Pandora's Promise
  • Part 810
  • Patrick Moore
  • Paul Allen
  • Paul Genoa
  • PCAST
  • Pennsylvania
  • Peter Bradford
  • petition
  • PG&E
  • Pilgrim
  • Pilgrim Nuclear Power Startion
  • Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station
  • Plamt Vogtle
  • Plant Vogtle
  • Plutonium
  • Poland
  • policy
  • polls
  • President Obama
  • Presidential Debates
  • pressurized thermal shock
  • Progress Energy
  • progressive politics
  • Progressives for Nuclear Progress
  • Public Health
  • public opinion
  • public service announcement
  • Quad Cities
  • R. William Borchardt
  • Rachel Doss
  • Rachel Maddow
  • racing
  • radiation
  • radio media tour
  • radioisotope thermoelectric generator
  • Rancho Seco
  • Reddit
  • refueling outage
  • regulation
  • Renault
  • renewable energy
  • renewables
  • Rep. John Shimkus
  • Rep. Mike Simpson
  • research reactors
  • Revolution
  • Richard Branson
  • Richard Myers
  • Richard Rhodes
  • Riverkeeper
  • Robert Alvarez
  • Robert F. Kennedy
  • Robert N. Charette
  • Robert Stone
  • Rolls-Royce
  • Rosatom
  • Russell Gocht
  • Russia
  • safety
  • safety culture
  • San Diego Union-Tribune
  • San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station
  • Savannah River Site
  • SCANA
  • SCANA. VC Summer
  • Scientific American
  • Scotland
  • Seabrook Nuclear Power Plant
  • Section 123 Agreements
  • security
  • Sen. Jeff Bingaman
  • Senator Barbara Boxer
  • Senator Harry Reid
  • September 11
  • Sequoyah Nuclear Power Plant
  • Sharknado
  • Shaw Group
  • Sierra Club
  • Simona De Silvestro
  • Singapore
  • slovakia
  • Small Modular Reactor
  • small reactors
  • solar
  • solar energy
  • Solyndra
  • South Africa
  • South Australia
  • South Carolina
  • South Korea
  • South Texas Project
  • Southern California Edison
  • Southern Company
  • space travel
  • Spent Fuel Pool
  • Stanford University
  • State Department
  • State-of-the-Art Reactor Consequence Analyses (SOARCA)
  • Station Blackout
  • steam generators
  • STEM
  • Steve Byrne
  • Steve Kerekes
  • Steven Chu
  • Stewart Brand
  • storage
  • subsidies
  • Summer nuclear station
  • Sundance
  • Suvrat Raju
  • Switzerland
  • tanks
  • television
  • Temelin
  • Tennessee Valley Authority
  • Tepco
  • TerraPower
  • Thailand
  • The Guardian
  • The New Yorker
  • The Simpsons
  • Thorium
  • TIME Magazine
  • TIP Award
  • Tom Fanning
  • Tom Farrell
  • Tom Laughlin
  • Tom Moore
  • Tomioka
  • Tony Alexander
  • Tony Pietrangelo
  • Toronto
  • Tritium
  • Trojan
  • Tufts University
  • Tugg
  • Turkey
  • Turkey Point
  • TVA
  • U.S. News and World Report
  • U.S. P.I.R.G.
  • UAE
  • UBS
  • UCS
  • Underground
  • Underground Piping
  • union of concerned scientists
  • United Arab Emirates
  • United Kingdom
  • University of Florida
  • University of Missouri
  • University of South Carolina
  • University of Texas at Austin
  • uprates
  • uranium
  • Uranium Mining
  • USEC
  • Used Fuel
  • Used fuel pool
  • used nuclear fuel
  • Utah
  • Vatican City
  • Vermont
  • Vermont Yankee
  • Victor Gilinsky. Vietnam
  • Vietnam
  • Virginia
  • Visaginas
  • vogtle
  • Wall Street
  • Wall Street Journal
  • warheads
  • Washington Post
  • waste
  • waste confidence
  • Waste Isolation Pilot Plant
  • water consumption
  • Watts Bar
  • We The People
  • welding
  • Westinghouse
  • White House
  • wind
  • wind energy
  • Windham County
  • wipp
  • Wisconsin
  • Women In Nuclear
  • World Bank
  • World Energy Outlook
  • world nuclear association
  • World Nuclear Fuel Conference
  • Yucca Mountain
  • Yukiya Amano
  • zion

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (241)
    • ►  December (12)
    • ►  November (11)
    • ►  October (26)
    • ►  September (24)
    • ►  August (12)
    • ►  July (13)
    • ▼  June (31)
      • “Nuclear is indispensable as part of the global en...
      • Why Extension of the U.S.-ROK Peaceful Nuclear Coo...
      • Insistence on the “Gold Standard” in Nuclear Trade...
      • Move Along, Nothing to See Here: The President’s U...
      • Carbon-Free Nuclear Energy Must Play Strong Role t...
      • Excerpts from President Obama’s Climate Action Pla...
      • Nuclear Numbers Up in France
      • VIDEO: Simona De Silvestro on Parallels between In...
      • Memo to Fox News: Nuclear Weapons and Nuclear Ener...
      • Song of SONGS: The Moral Dimension of Nuclear Energy
      • Pandora’s Promise in Review
      • Does Nuclear Energy Still Have a Future? You Bette...
      • The Power of Doubt in Pandora’s Promise
      • Did Pandora's Promise Miss John Kerry's Change of ...
      • A Brief Review of Pandora's Promise
      • Lost in the Nuclear Clouds
      • Robert Stone and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. Clash Afte...
      • Reactions to San Onofre Closing: It “ought to jolt...
      • Where Can I See the Nuclear Energy Documentary Pan...
      • NEI on the San Onofre Shutdown
      • Giant Digital Simulator Enhances D.C. Cook Plant T...
      • Why You Can't Trust Joe Mangano and the Blue Ridge...
      • NextEra Sets Record With 700-MW Power Uprate
      • Duke Examines 6,500 Oconee Reactor Parts in One Re...
      • What Gets Sacrificed in a Nuclear Energy Shutdown
      • Shift in Clinton Plant Refueling Cycle Increases E...
      • Rep. John Shimkus on Yucca Mountain: Can You Hear ...
      • New Welding Process Saves Calvert Cliffs $17.5 Mil...
      • National Academy of Sciences Says Offshore Fisheri...
      • The Tatemae and Honne of Reopening Nuclear Plants
      • NEA 2013 CEO Panel Video is Must See TV for Nuclea...
    • ►  May (19)
    • ►  April (23)
    • ►  March (23)
    • ►  February (23)
    • ►  January (24)
  • ►  2012 (259)
    • ►  December (12)
    • ►  November (11)
    • ►  October (24)
    • ►  September (17)
    • ►  August (27)
    • ►  July (22)
    • ►  June (28)
    • ►  May (23)
    • ►  April (33)
    • ►  March (25)
    • ►  February (28)
    • ►  January (9)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile